In today’s world, finding affordable and effective healthcare coverage for your family can feel like navigating a maze. Rising premiums, complex insurance policies, and limited options often leave families searching for alternatives. One option gaining traction is healthshare plans, a unique approach to managing medical costs that emphasizes community, shared values, and affordability. But with so many choices, how do you pick the right healthshare plan for your family? This guide breaks it down, offering practical insights to help you make an informed decision.
What Are Healthshare Plans?

Healthshare plans are not traditional insurance. Instead, they’re cooperative programs where members pool their resources to cover each other’s medical expenses. Often rooted in shared values, many healthshare plans are faith-based, requiring members to align with certain ethical or religious principles. Monthly contributions from members go toward a collective fund, which is then used to pay eligible medical bills for participants. This model can offer significant savings compared to conventional insurance, but it comes with distinct differences that families need to understand.
Some popular programs, such as Medishare insurance offered through companies like HSA for America, have become well-known for blending affordability with a values-driven healthcare alternative. Families drawn to these types of plans often appreciate the combination of financial relief and supportive community aspects.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Healthshare Plan

Selecting a healthshare plan involves evaluating several factors to ensure it aligns with your family’s healthcare needs, budget, and values. Here’s what to keep in mind:
1. Coverage and Eligibility
Unlike traditional insurance, healthshare plans often have specific guidelines about what medical expenses are eligible for sharing. Some plans cover major medical expenses like hospitalizations or surgeries but may exclude preventive care, maternity, or pre-existing conditions. Others offer more comprehensive options, including primary care or wellness visits. Review the plan’s guidelines carefully to understand what’s covered and what’s not.
For families with young children or expecting parents, check whether maternity care or pediatric services are included. If anyone in your family has a chronic condition, confirm how pre-existing conditions are handled, as some plans impose waiting periods or limitations.
2. Cost and Contributions
One of the biggest draws of healthshare plans is their affordability. Monthly contributions are often significantly lower than traditional insurance premiums, sometimes by as much as 50%. However, costs can vary based on the plan, family size, and coverage level. Some plans also require an initial unshareable amount (similar to a deductible) before cost-sharing kicks in.
When comparing plans, calculate the total annual cost, including monthly contributions and any out-of-pocket expenses. Consider whether the plan allows flexibility in contributions based on your budget or if it offers discounts for healthy lifestyles.
3. Faith-Based or Non-Denominational Options
Many healthshare plans are rooted in Christian values, requiring members to sign a statement of faith or adhere to certain lifestyle commitments, such as avoiding tobacco or excessive alcohol use. These plans appeal to families who want their healthcare dollars to support like-minded communities. However, non-denominational healthshare plans are also available for those who prefer a values-based approach without religious requirements. Decide which type aligns with your family’s beliefs and preferences.
4. Provider Flexibility
If you live in Colorado, it’s worth comparing healthshare programs with Colorado Health Insurance options available through ColoHealth. They can help you weigh the advantages of traditional insurance against healthshare plans to ensure you find the right fit for your family’s needs.
5. Community and Support
Healthshare plans often foster a sense of community, with members supporting each other through shared contributions and, in some cases, personal encouragement. Some plans even allow direct member-to-member sharing, where contributions go directly to another member’s medical bills. Consider whether this community aspect is important to your family and how much administrative support the plan provides for submitting and processing bills.
Benefits of Healthshare Plans for Families
Healthshare plans offer several advantages that make them appealing for families:
- Affordability: Monthly contributions are often lower than insurance premiums, freeing up funds for other family priorities.
- Flexibility: Many plans allow you to choose providers without network restrictions, giving you control over your healthcare.
- Community Focus: The shared values and mutual support can create a sense of belonging, especially for faith-based families.
- Tax Advantages: Some healthshare plans can be paired with a Health Savings Account (HSA) when combined with a minimum essential coverage (MEC) plan, offering tax-free savings for medical expenses.
Potential Drawbacks to Watch For
While healthshare plans have many benefits, they’re not without risks. Here are some potential drawbacks:
- Limited Coverage: Healthshare plans may not cover certain treatments, such as mental health services, substance abuse treatment, or elective procedures. Always review the fine print.
- No Legal Obligation: Unlike insurance companies, healthshare plans aren’t legally required to pay claims, which can lead to uncertainty in catastrophic situations.
- Pre-Existing Conditions: Some plans have waiting periods or exclusions for pre-existing conditions, which could impact families with ongoing medical needs.
- Administrative Burden: Submitting bills for sharing can require more effort than traditional insurance, as members may need to coordinate with providers directly.
Tips for Choosing the Right Healthshare Plan
- Assess Your Family’s Needs: Consider your family’s health history, lifestyle, and medical needs. Do you need coverage for routine care, or are you primarily looking for protection against major medical expenses?
- Compare Multiple Plans: Research several healthshare plans to find one that matches your budget and coverage requirements. Look for transparency in guidelines and member reviews.
- Consult a Professional: A personal benefits advisor can help you navigate the complexities of healthshare plans and compare them to traditional insurance options.
- Read Member Guidelines: Pay close attention to the plan’s rules, including lifestyle requirements, eligible expenses, and sharing limits.
- Check for HSA Compatibility: If you want to maximize tax savings, look for plans that can be paired with an HSA-qualified MEC plan.
Is a Healthshare Plan Right for Your Family?
Healthshare plans can be a game-changer for families seeking affordable, values-driven healthcare. They’re especially well-suited for healthy families who don’t anticipate frequent medical expenses and want to save on monthly costs. However, if your family has significant medical needs or prefers the predictability of traditional insurance, a healthshare plan may not be the best fit.
Take the time to evaluate your options, weigh the pros and cons, and consider consulting a benefits advisor to ensure you’re making the best choice for your family’s health and financial future. By choosing a healthshare plan that aligns with your values and needs, you can gain peace of mind knowing you’re part of a community that supports one another in times of need.

Jean Smith is a fitness enthusiast and blogger who focuses on fitness and a healthy lifestyle. She is passionate about assisting people in living healthier lifestyles and is constantly on the lookout for new and creative methods to stay fit and healthy. Her articles are excellent resources for anyone interested in improving their health and fitness.